Listen to the full Podcast:

Follow on TikTok: @pardonmytake
Follow on Twitter:
Follow on Instagram:
Follow on Twitch:


Check out Barstool Sports for more:

Follow Barstool Sports here:


  1. To those of you who don’t agree with Crosby being a top 5 GOAT – every player in the NHL would disagree with you. You are ignorant…

  2. Crosby fans have brain damage. The guy ranks 36 in all time scoring. Saying crosby is the goat would be the same as saying James Harden or Pau Gasol is better than Lebron.

    Let’s be real people. Crosby is not a top 3 penguin (Lemieux, Malkin Jagr, Paul Coffey, Ron Francis, Fleury easily outrank him).

    Also, if he is so great. Why does he have more than half of his playoff runs ending in a first round exit

  3. Best Players Of All Time
    1. Wayne Gretzky
    2. Mario Lemieux
    3. Sidney Crosby
    4. Bobby Orr
    5. Peter Forsberg

    Best Goal Scorers
    1. Mario Lemieux
    2. Wayne Gretzky
    3. Alex Ovechkin
    4. Mike Bossy
    5. Pavel Bure

    Best Playermakers Of All Time
    1. Wayne Gretzky
    2. Peter Forsberg
    3. Joe Thornton
    4. Pavel Datsyuk
    5. Sidney Crosby

    Most Talented Players Of All Time
    1. Mario Lemieux
    2. Sidney Crosby
    3. Alex Ovechkin
    4. Pavel Datsyuk
    5. Ilya Kovalchuk
    6. Alex Kovalev
    7. Pavel Bure
    8. Peter Forsberg
    9. Gilbert Perreault
    10. Jaromir Jagr

    Greatest All Around Players
    1. Peter Forsberg
    2. Pavel Datsyuk
    3. Sergei Federov
    4. Steve Yzerman
    5. Bobby Clarke

  4. Crosby is easily the best since he was drafted. Not sure he’s top 5 though. Thats a lot of mountains of legends to climb just being respectful. Top 10 without a doubt.

  5. I’d say Crosby is definitely top 25, maybe top 15. I’d have to make a list. Can’t forget Forsberg, Sakic, Messier, Yzerman. There have been so many great great players.

  6. Not sure if he is top 5 all time. He certainly is the greatest player of his era. Top 5 in Crosby era
    1. Crosby
    2. Anze Kopitar
    3. Patrick Kane
    4. Gino Malkin
    5. Jonathan Toews.

Comments are closed.